Silver

Silver Futures Fall More Than Gold on November 20

Silver fell harder than gold. The CFTC's Nov. 17 count shows where traders stood before Friday's selloff, with the December Fed decision ahead.

by Corinne Ashdown4 min read

A pitted silver switch contact sits on a scratched copper arm on a dark steel workbench.
Equedia on
Listen to this article0:00 / 4:55

December silver futures settled at US$41.07 a troy ounce on Nov. 20, down 7.4% by our arithmetic from CME Group's settlement table updated at 11:55 p.m. CT. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission's futures-only report shows non-commercial traders held more long than short contracts in standard COMEX silver futures on Nov. 17.

December gold futures fell 4.6% on Nov. 20 by the same calculation, using CME's gold settlements updated at 11:55 p.m. CT. In a separate weekly price snapshot on Nov. 20, updated at 4:34 p.m. EST, Kitco News put silver prices down more than 15% and gold prices down roughly 9.5%. Kitco put both metals' prices at 14-month lows.

Why is silver dropping faster than gold? A firmer dollar raises the local cost of either metal for buyers whose currencies weaken, while higher rates make it costlier to hold bullion that pays no interest. Those are the shared pressures we covered in Gold Slides as Traders Bet on a December Fed Hike. Silver also has uses in electronics, so a weaker outlook for factory demand could weigh on it separately. A copper recovery without a silver rebound would make us look harder for selling specific to silver. The price and positioning reports don't show that factory demand expectations weakened on Friday or establish why silver fell harder than gold.

A rush to raise cash can also make a drop steeper. In its Nov. 20 report, Reuters quoted a metals trader on how selling can spread from stocks to bullion:

The ongoing AI-related equity selloff is prompting some forced liquidations of gold positions to cover losses.

David Meger, who leads metals trading at High Ridge Futures, was speaking about gold. The same mechanism can reach silver: a trader asked to post more cash against losses elsewhere can sell silver to raise it. Tuesday's CFTC snapshot can't tell us whether that happened in silver on Friday.

Non-Commercial Traders Were Net Long on Nov. 17

In standard COMEX silver futures, the CFTC counted 35,995 longs and 17,704 shorts among non-commercial traders on Nov. 17. That left a net long of 18,291 contracts, equivalent to about 91 million troy ounces at the standard contract size. The net position had narrowed since Nov. 10, with 917 more shorts and 156 fewer longs in the CFTC's count. Traders who still hold longs can add to the selling if they cut risk. The Tuesday snapshot leaves open how many of those contracts are still held, and the ounce equivalent measures exposure without counting bars changing hands.

If you own the iShares Silver Trust (NYSE Arca: SLV) or Sprott Physical Silver Trust (NYSE Arca: PSLV), the market price of your holding can fall faster than the value of the bullion behind it. Sprott's Nov. 20 NYSE Arca closing data, updated at 6 p.m. EST, showed PSLV closing 6.11% below net asset value. That's the value of the trust's assets less liabilities, divided by its units outstanding. A narrowing discount can help your return even if silver goes sideways; a wider one can eat into a recovery.

A lower price on each ounce can take a bigger percentage out of a silver miner's margin than out of the silver price if costs hold steady. The same arithmetic helps on the way back up, although it runs on the price the miner actually receives, which can differ from the futures quote if it has hedged sales.

A softer dollar and lower short-term yields could offer some relief. If both ease and silver keeps losing ground to gold, we'd give less weight to the dollar and rate explanations and check the next CFTC count for a drop in outright longs. The Fed's Dec. 8 to 9 meeting brings the next rate decision and new economic projections on Dec. 9.

Seek the truth and be prepared,

Equedia News

Sources

Disclaimer: This letter is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Past predictions and performance are not indicative of future results. We own gold and gold stocks. Please see our full terms of use and disclaimer at equedia.com.

Many of our readers have made more than $100,000

Subscribe to our FREE monthly newsletter and see how many of our readers have made thousands in PROFITS with our ideas

Related Articles