PSLV vs SLV: What You Own and What You Pay
PSLV vs SLV comes down to who can redeem bars, what you pay to hold them and which US and Canadian tax rules you need to check.
by Corinne Ashdown9 min read

The key difference in PSLV vs SLV is who can redeem for bullion. Under the iShares prospectus dated Dec. 22, 2022, only registered broker-dealers known as Authorized Participants can purchase and redeem SLV baskets. The Sprott prospectus dated Jan. 20, 2026 describes a Canadian closed-end trust holding physical silver, and eligible PSLV unitholders can request delivery. Both hold silver, but only SLV has a standing dealer mechanism for exchanging bullion for new shares and shares for bullion.
You can buy or sell either through a broker without handling the metal. What you keep depends on the price you pay relative to the trust's silver, the expenses that come out of the trust and the tax rules for your account. Even if silver prices stand still, a change in what the market will pay for the same holdings can leave you with a gain or a loss.
How SLV's Basket Trades Pull It Toward NAV
iShares Silver Trust (NYSE Arca: SLV) can issue or take back shares in exchange for bullion. It does so in baskets, and the prospectus sets a minimum size for a basket trade:
The Trust issues and redeems Shares only in blocks of 50,000 or integral multiples thereof.
That's the threshold given in the Dec. 22, 2022 iShares prospectus. The dealers permitted to make these trades have agreements with the trust's sponsor and trustee. You and I normally sell to another investor on the exchange.
Net asset value, or NAV, is what the trust's assets are worth after liabilities. We divide that by the shares outstanding to get NAV per share. When SLV trades above NAV per share, an authorized dealer can deliver silver, receive newly issued shares and sell them. That adds shares to the market. If SLV trades below NAV, a dealer can buy shares and redeem a basket for silver, taking those shares out of circulation. Either trade needs a gap large enough to pay for execution. The mechanism can narrow the gap without guaranteeing that the market price and NAV are equal at any given moment.
Where the Silver Sits and Who Can Redeem
Both trusts hold physical silver. SLV names JPMorgan Chase Bank N.A., London branch, as its custodian. That identifies the institution responsible for the silver; it does not give us a location for every bar. The shelf prospectus identifies Sprott Physical Silver Trust (NYSE Arca: PSLV) as an Ontario trust set up to invest almost entirely in physical silver. The cover does not establish the name or location of its bullion custodian. That is a detail to confirm in the full custody provisions if the vault jurisdiction is part of your reason for choosing a trust.
With PSLV, the delivery option has a size threshold. The Sprott redemption instructions point to the January 2026 prospectus supplement and specify a monthly process requiring enough units to cover ten bars of roughly 1,000 ounces each. A small holder who wants to turn units into cash can sell on the exchange without meeting that threshold. For a holder large enough to take bars, the notice deadline and the arrangements for transporting and storing the metal are part of the decision.
In Is There a Silver Shortage?, we separated selling a share from redeeming it. A sale transfers the security between investors. A completed bullion redemption releases metal from the trust. When you buy either security, you own an interest in the trust's assets. The redemption terms determine whether you can turn that interest into bars.
Why PSLV's Price Can Stay Away From NAV
PSLV lacks the standing two-way dealer mechanism that can pull SLV's price toward NAV. But closed-end does not mean the supply of units is fixed. Sprott's Jan. 20, 2026 prospectus supplement qualifies an offering of up to US$2 billion in units. Any sales under the offering would take place at then-prevailing prices, with the net proceeds designated for purchases of physical silver bullion.
When buyers bid units above NAV, the trust can add supply through an offering, but the supplement doesn't promise a sale whenever the units trade at a premium. When units trade below NAV, the monthly bullion redemption has a minimum, and a would-be redeemer still has to make the deal pay after costs. A discount can persist if buyers won't pay NAV and too few holders are willing and able to redeem. The discount is the difference between the price and NAV per unit, expressed as a share of NAV. A premium is the same calculation when the price is above NAV.
The supplement gives us a dated example. For the Jan. 16, 2026 NYSE Arca close, it reports US$29.39 for PSLV against a NAV of US$30.8406 per unit. By our arithmetic, the units traded about 4.7% below their asset value. If NAV had stayed flat and the price had moved up to NAV, the buyer would have gained about 4.9% before costs. The return is measured against the price paid, which is lower than the NAV used to calculate the discount.
At its Nov. 19, 2026 update at 6 p.m. EST, Sprott's pricing page showed a 4.07% discount for the US listing. The iShares fund page reports a closing price of US$39.64 for SLV on Nov. 19, 2026 and a NAV of US$40.63 for that session. That is a discount of roughly 2.4%, by our arithmetic from the displayed figures.
NYSE Arca closing discounts to NAV, percent below NAV
Source: Sprott prospectus supplement and pricing page; iShares fund page. All observations are from 2026.
| Label | Value |
|---|---|
| PSLV Jan. 16 | 4.7 |
| PSLV Nov. 19 | 4.07 |
| SLV Nov. 19 | 2.4 |
These snapshots show that both trusts can trade below NAV. They leave open how wide the gap usually runs, and when the bullion valuation and exchange price use different clocks, a closing gap can pick up a move in silver between those readings. We'd compare the same listing in the same currency over several closes. If you buy and later sell at the same percentage discount, the discount contributes nothing to your percentage return relative to NAV. A wider gap at exit reduces the return on the units relative to the change in NAV per unit.
What US Holders Can Verify Before Buying
For US individuals in taxable accounts, the tax question is whether a long-term gain qualifies for the regular capital gains schedule or is subject to the collectibles rules. The IRS capital gains guidance for 2025 puts the maximum federal rate for net long-term collectibles gains at 28%, before any applicable net investment income tax. The regular federal schedule topped out at 20% that year, also before any applicable net investment income tax. The prospectus cover verifies what SLV owns, but which rate schedule applies to a sale of SLV shares turns on the trust-specific federal tax provisions farther into the full prospectus. We leave that treatment open here.
PSLV falls under the US passive foreign investment company rules, or PFIC rules. Under Sprott's 2025 US tax guide, a US individual with a timely, effective qualified electing fund election can generally get regular long-term capital gains treatment on units held for more than a year. The rate and any benefit depend on the individual's taxable income. The guide treats a US retirement account separately, so the taxable sale rate comparison doesn't automatically carry over.
A qualified electing fund election, or QEF election, generally goes on IRS Form 8621 with the federal return for the first tax year you own the units. The election is generally made once, and the form is generally filed every year after that. QEF holders use it to report any ordinary income and net capital gains allocated to them, even without a payout. Sprott's guide describes a separate deemed-sale election for holders who missed the first-year election and warns that a gain on that deemed sale can carry ordinary income taxes and an interest charge.
How Canada Taxes a Sale
For a Canadian resident who holds either trust as capital property in a non-registered account, a sale generally gives rise to a capital gain or loss under Canada Revenue Agency guidance. The IRS rate comparison doesn't set the Canadian rate. That answer also assumes you're holding the units as an investment on capital account. It does not settle registered-plan or dual-filer treatment.
Sprott's shelf prospectus lists PSLV in Canadian dollars on the TSX and PSLV.U in US dollars. Both are quotes for the same class of units. Changing the quote currency does not change the assets backing the units. A Canadian-dollar line can be simpler to trade with Canadian dollars already in the account. How to calculate and report a foreign-currency disposition is a separate question for the complete CRA reporting guidance and your circumstances; the listing alone cannot answer it.
Which Trust Fits the Way You Hold Silver
The fee figures alone don't establish which trust costs more to own. The Nov. 19, 2026 fund pages show a 0.50% sponsor fee for SLV and a 0.53% management expense ratio for PSLV. The sponsor fee is a charge for running SLV; the management expense ratio measures expenses borne by PSLV relative to its assets. Applying the difference between those published percentages to a hypothetical US$10,000 balance for a year yields about US$3, by our arithmetic. That's a comparison of the percentages on the same balance. The bid-ask spread, currency conversion and any change in the NAV discount have separate effects on the investor's return.
If you want exchange-traded silver and value a mechanism designed to pull price toward NAV, SLV gives dealers more direct ways to close a gap. It can still trade at a discount. PSLV offers a route to bullion for eligible holders and potential regular long-term treatment for a US individual with a valid election. Its discount can widen while you own it, and US taxable QEF holders have paperwork in years without a payout. If taking delivery is part of your plan, the published minimum is a better first test than the difference between the expense figures.
We'd revisit a PSLV purchase made for its discount at the next comparable close and again before selling. A widening discount means your market-price return falls behind the change in NAV per unit over the same holding period. For a US taxable holder, the next annual document to check is Sprott's PFIC statement for the year ending Dec. 31, 2026, ahead of filing that year's return.
The silver can be worth more when you sell and the units can still earn you less than the bars did.
Seek the truth and be prepared,
Equedia
Sources
- iShares Silver Trust, Dec. 22, 2022 prospectus filed with the SEC
- Sprott Physical Silver Trust, Jan. 20, 2026 short form base shelf prospectus
- Sprott, How to Redeem
- Sprott Physical Silver Trust, Jan. 20, 2026 prospectus supplement
- Sprott, Physical Silver Trust pricing and expenses
- iShares, Silver Trust pricing and sponsor fee
- Internal Revenue Service, Capital gains and losses
- Sprott, 2025 Tax Guide for US Investors
- Internal Revenue Service, Instructions for Form 8621
- Canada Revenue Agency, Calculating and reporting your capital gains and losses
- Equedia, Is There a Silver Shortage?
Disclaimer: This letter is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Past predictions and performance are not indicative of future results. Please see our full terms of use and disclaimer at equedia.com.






