Is There a Silver Shortage?
The Silver Institute forecasts a sixth straight deficit in 2026. We compare it with vault stocks and show what would signal a silver shortage.
by Corinne Ashdown8 min read

Is there a silver shortage? The Silver Institute's Nov. 12, 2026 update forecasts a global deficit of 35 million troy ounces for the year before flows into or out of exchange-traded silver funds. That gap between the year's supply and demand does not establish a worldwide shortage of metal for immediate delivery. A buyer who can get a bar from an existing holder can still take delivery.
In the same update, the Institute said that metal released through fund selling had helped ease physical tightness. Gross vault totals put the deficit in perspective, but they don't tell us which bars are on offer. The cost to borrow metal and the premium to get it on short notice give us a better test of availability.
How Big Is the Silver Deficit?
The 2026 deficit would be the sixth straight, bringing the cumulative shortfall since 2021 to about 746 million ounces in the Institute's November forecast. The year-by-year figures in the Institute's supply and demand table show the gap narrowing well before the latest forecast. Six years of deficits can sound like six years of worsening scarcity, even though the biggest annual gap in this run came near the beginning.
Annual silver deficits before fund flows, million troy ounces
Source: Silver Institute and Metals Focus, November 12, 2026, market balance row shown as shortfalls
| Label | Value |
|---|---|
| 2021 | 84 |
| 2022 | 254 |
| 2023 | 195 |
| 2024 | 124 |
| 2025 | 54 |
| 2026 forecast | 35 |
The supply side already includes recycling. In the November update, mine production is forecast at 834 million ounces for 2026, while recycling is forecast at 210 million. A refiner turning old jewellery into new supply is already captured in that balance. An investor selling an existing wholesale bar without melting it down can make metal available without adding to the recycling line.
The cumulative figure is a sum of annual balances before fund flows. It does not tell us where the metal came from or how much remains with owners willing to sell. We can check some of the places silver is held, though each report measures something different.
Where the Missing Silver Comes From
A silver deficit can be covered by above-ground stocks when someone who already owns metal sells it. The London Bullion Market Association's vault report counted 28,889 tonnes of silver at the end of October 2026. Using its conversion factor, we get about 928.8 million troy ounces at the end of that month. The November 2026 forecast deficit amounts to about 3.8% of London's end-October stock, by our arithmetic. That's a scale comparison between a year's flow and one month's closing stock. It gives us no estimate of how many London ounces are offered for sale.
The COMEX silver warehouse report dated Nov. 17, 2026 lists registered and eligible stocks separately. Neither label tells you whether the owner wants to sell. For the Nov. 16 activity date, the report showed about 101.8 million ounces registered out of 331.0 million ounces in all.
A bar can change categories without leaving the warehouse. In that report, one depository shifted about 4,982 ounces from registered to eligible in the adjustment column, with its total unchanged and neither receipts nor withdrawals. A fall in registered metal alone can tell you less about how much silver physically left than the withdrawal column on the same line of reporting.
The iShares Silver Trust's holdings page reports a separate ownership count. The trust (NYSE Arca: SLV) held about 500.1 million ounces on Nov. 18, 2026. Trust holdings are counted by owner, while the vault reports count by location. Fund bars can sit in reporting vaults, which is why adding holdings to warehouse totals can count a bar twice. The public figures here don't settle the overlap.
Reported silver stocks for scale, million troy ounces
Source: LBMA, COMEX and iShares, October to November 2026
| Label | Value |
|---|---|
| London (end Oct.) | 928.8 |
| COMEX total (Nov. 16) | 331.0 |
| COMEX registered (Nov. 16) | 101.8 |
| SLV (Nov. 18) | 500.1 |
These counts measure different things on different dates and should not be added.
How Fund Redemptions Can Release Silver
An exchange-traded product, or ETP, can give you exposure to silver through shares you trade on an exchange. Selling shares to another investor needn't move a bar. The iShares Silver Trust prospectus explains how bullion can come out: authorized broker-dealers can redeem large blocks of shares in exchange for silver. That metal can be sold or used elsewhere. You don't need a truck to leave the vault for a bar to change hands.
The Institute's November table puts ETP flows below the headline supply and demand balance. It forecasts 45 million ounces of net ETP outflows in 2026, more than the 35 million ounces in the headline deficit. The result is a projected surplus of 10 million ounces for 2026 after ETP flows, on the table's own terms. Neither balance says that miners and recyclers produced a surplus or that every buyer can source bars on their preferred terms.
The narrower shortfall and metal released through ETP selling have helped ease physical market tightness.
That is how the Institute described the physical market in its November update. If funds switch to taking in metal while the underlying deficit persists, new fund demand would compete with other buyers for bars. A change in fund flows can therefore alter the availability of bullion before a new mine or refinery contributes an ounce.
Why Silver Prices Can Fall in a Deficit
Silver prices can fall in a deficit because the price reflects what buyers and sellers will pay or accept now, while the deficit counts ounces over the year. The World Bank's Nov. 4, 2026 price analysis shows average silver prices fell 11.6% in October from September. The annual deficit forecast and a lower monthly price can both be right.
For the retreat from the January 2026 price peak into early November, the Silver Institute cited shifting US interest-rate expectations, a stronger dollar and rising bond yields. Silver bullion pays no interest, so higher yields raise the income you forgo by holding it. At the same time, the Institute forecast lower total silver demand for 2026. Among industrial users, solar manufacturers were cutting the amount of silver they used or substituting other materials. The demand outlook can weaken even while the market still needs some metal from existing stocks.
In What Is the Gold-Silver Ratio?, we showed how silver lost more than gold in October even though both fell in dollars. That comparison gives you a measure of relative weakness. It cannot tell you whether a manufacturer in London can borrow bars for a shipment, any more than an annual deficit can tell you where the next trade will clear.
What a Physical Shortage Would Show
A shortage of deliverable bars would show up in the terms buyers pay for immediate metal. We'd look for lease rates rising, meaning it costs more to borrow silver. The Silver Institute's April 2026 release summary describes elevated lease rates and regional tightness in 2025 as metal shifted into CME vaults. A bar arriving in one market can do little for a borrower in another who needs it on short notice.
We'd also look for persistent backwardation, when metal for immediate delivery costs more than metal for later delivery. CME's explanation of the futures curve notes that keeping a production line running can make owning the physical material now more valuable. A premium for prompt wholesale bars over their usual benchmark would give us another check in the same market. The premium on a retail coin doesn't tell us what a buyer pays above benchmark for prompt wholesale bars.
These documents don't establish a current reading for wholesale lease rates, the forward curve or physical premiums. We would want the signals to agree across more than a single delivery date or trading session before treating tightness as persistent. Establishing that it is widespread would take evidence from more than one delivery market.
When We Get the Next Read on Silver
The next London vault count is the first inventory test of whether November drew down the London stocks cited here. The LBMA's fifth-business-day cadence puts the next count, for November 2026 holdings, around Dec. 7. The next COMEX warehouse sheets let us check whether bars actually leave approved warehouses or just move between categories. The World Bank lists Dec. 2, 2026 for its next Pink Sheet, which gives us November's average price, a separate check on whether bullion prices continued to fall. The Institute's November release gives no confirmed date for the next full annual balance.
If you own silver, a reversal from fund outflows to inflows could leave more buyers competing for the same deliverable bars. The risk in buying on the deficit alone is that holders keep supplying metal while industrial users buy less. We'd revisit our reading at the December vault update if stocks fall alongside sustained backwardation and rising wholesale borrowing costs and premiums. Falling vault totals alone tell us that less is held at those locations, while leaving open whether the bars moved to other vaults and whether local buyers are paying more.
The deficit measures the gap before fund flows; the premium over a comparable wholesale benchmark tells you what buyers pay extra for prompt delivery.
Seek the truth and be prepared,
Equedia
Sources
- Silver Institute, Silver Market Set for Sixth Consecutive Annual Deficit in 2026
- Silver Institute and Metals Focus, November silver supply and demand table
- London Bullion Market Association, London Vault Data
- CME Group, COMEX Silver Metal Depository Statistics
- iShares, iShares Silver Trust holdings and listing
- iShares, iShares Silver Trust prospectus
- World Bank, October commodity price analysis
- Silver Institute, Press release archive with April World Silver Survey release summary
- CME Group, What Is Contango and Backwardation?
- World Bank, Commodity Markets and Pink Sheet release schedule
- Equedia, What Is the Gold-Silver Ratio?
Disclaimer: This letter is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Past predictions and performance are not indicative of future results. We own gold and gold stocks. Please see our full terms of use and disclaimer at equedia.com.






