Gold

How to Buy Physical Gold: Coins or Bars?

How to buy physical gold starts with what you can get back. A coin and a kilo bar show how resale, storage, insurance and taxes shape your costs.

by Corinne Ashdown8 min read

An empty coin capsule rests on felt at a glass counter with a desk lamp in the background.
Equedia on
Listen to this article0:00 / 9:59

When we decide how to buy physical gold, we want a purchase quote and a buyback bid for the same piece before we pay. The U.S. Mint's coin archive distinguishes bullion coins meant for investment from proof and uncirculated issues marketed to collectors. For a first purchase, we favour a standard bullion coin or a small bar that you can price with more than one buyer.

In our Nov. 20, 2026 example, a coin containing one troy ounce of fine gold costs a hypothetical US$3,605. An immediate buyback at unchanged spot would bring a hypothetical US$3,465. If the dealer keeps its bid at the same percentage discount to spot, the gold price has to rise for the buyer to close that gap.

A First Purchase Should Be Easy to Price and Sell

A local coin shop gives you a chance to see the product and find out what the shop would pay to take it back. An online bullion seller lets you compare the same item across more sellers, but the delivered price has to include any shipping, insurance and payment fees.

A purchase that goes straight to a vault is another route. There, what you get in writing about ownership and withdrawal is as important as the order confirmation.

Gold bullion is metal sold chiefly for its gold content. We would compare a bar and a coin on their fine gold weight, which is the amount of gold they contain, rather than on their gross weight or the face value stamped on a coin. An assay is a check of metal content. A bar's refiner, fineness mark and accompanying documentation give a prospective buyer something to check against when it wants to verify the piece.

The Royal Canadian Mint's bullion page identifies the Gold Maple Leaf as a bullion coin and describes security features such as laser marking and precision radial lines. A familiar design gives you a named product to quote on both sides of the counter.

A secondhand piece that needs testing, or a bar whose packaging the buyer won't accept, can cost more to sell than the same weight of gold with documentation the dealer recognizes. That can change what the seller with the lowest price today is saving you.

What a Same-Day Buyback Would Cost

Spot is the reference price for gold for immediate delivery, usually shown per troy ounce. The premium is what the seller charges over the spot value of the gold in the piece. The dealer's bid is the price it offers to pay you. That bid can be under, at or above spot, so subtracting a presumed discount can give you the wrong resale price. We ran into the same distinction in What Is the Gold-Silver Ratio?: a quoted relationship between metals can move your way while the price of making the trade takes away the gain.

For the Nov. 20, 2026 comparison, we assume spot of US$3,500 per troy ounce for both products. We assume the coin costs 3% over spot and sells back at 1% under. That produces the US$3,605 purchase and the US$3,465 bid. The US$140 gap is the immediate loss and comes to 3.88% of the money put up.

The bar in the model contains a kilogram of fine gold, or about 32.15 troy ounces using the conversion in NIST Handbook 44, Appendix C. We assume an ask 1% above spot and a bid 0.5% below. On the same model date, the purchase costs about US$113,650 and the bid brings back about US$111,962. You give up about US$1,688 on an immediate resale, or 1.49% of the purchase price.

If the dealer keeps its bid at the same share of spot, the bid rises by the same percentage as the gold price. The spot rise needed to break even is therefore the dollar gap divided by the starting bid. The immediate loss uses the same gap divided by the higher purchase price, so it comes out smaller. Both calculations leave out shipping, storage, insurance and taxes.

Hypothetical Resale Loss and Break-Even Spot Rise, Percent

Source: Equedia calculation, hypothetical quotes dated Nov. 20, 2026, before carrying costs and tax.

Hypothetical Resale Loss and Break-Even Spot Rise, Percent
LabelValue
Coin resale loss3.88
Bar resale loss1.49
Coin spot rise4.04
Bar spot rise1.51

The dollar gap is larger on the bar in this example even though the percentage gap is smaller. You can reproduce the comparison at a shop by asking, at the same time, what the item costs delivered and what cash you would receive if the same item came back across the counter. With a mail-in buyback, we would ask when the dealer locks the bid so we know whether the eventual payout can change while the parcel is in transit.

Smaller Pieces Let You Raise Less Cash at a Time

For a small investor, the useful unit of gold is often the unit you might want to sell. A standard coin or a small bar lets you buy in stages and sell an individual piece. A large bar concentrates the holding in a single trade. If you need only part of its value in cash, you may have to sell the bar and pay another retail premium to buy back the gold you wanted to keep.

The choice changes when you can get equivalent small bars with a tighter spread. If their bids come from several willing buyers, you can get the same ability to sell in pieces without paying extra for a particular coin. Fractional coins lower the cash needed for each purchase, but their cost per ounce can go up if the seller charges more for making and handling each piece. Comparing the full quote per fine ounce shows what you're paying for that flexibility.

A good price from a seller that won't buy the item back still needs a resale quote from somewhere else. We would get that quote before assuming a limited edition, a proof finish or a particular refiner name will fetch the same premium on the way out that it did when you bought it.

Storage Adds a Bill Even When Gold Stands Still

Home storage gives you immediate access, with the cost of securing the metal and arranging insurance left to you. A bank box puts the metal outside your home, with rent and access tied to the branch. In either case, the insurance question is whether your policy actually covers bullion in that location, at what value and against what events.

For a vault, we'd check whether the custody agreement identifies a specific bar or a share of identified metal, and whose records show title. We'd also want to know whether the custodian can lend the metal, whose policy covers a loss and what it costs to take delivery.

If you already have a coin, a service that stores gold acquired through its own platform may charge differently or may not take your piece. A custody quote is only comparable when it covers what you intend to hold and lets you get it out in the form you expect.

As a fee example on Nov. 21, 2026, BullionVault's tariff lists gold custody including insurance at 0.12% a year. The monthly US$4 minimum adds up to US$48 over a full year if it applies each month. The tariff covers gold held through the account and gives us no price for storing a coin you bring in. A minimum charge takes a larger share of a small holding, which is why the dollar floor belongs in the comparison alongside the advertised percentage.

Purchase Tax and Tax on a Sale Are Separate

In the US, the tax charged at checkout, if any, goes into your cost. A later gain is a separate federal question. The IRS's Topic 409 displays 2025 rate thresholds. It says a capital gain or loss is generally long-term if you held the asset for more than one year. The maximum federal capital gains rate on net long-term collectibles gains is 28%.

The IRS names coins as an example of collectibles and measures a capital gain by the amount realized less adjusted basis. Net short-term gains are generally taxed at ordinary income rates. Topic 409 does not classify specific bullion bars, so we would confirm the treatment for the year of sale before assuming a rate.

The 2027 IRS instructions for Form 1099-B list sales of precious metals under exceptions for brokers. Before selling, we would check the instructions for the year of sale and ask the dealer whether the type and quantity we plan to sell trigger dealer reporting. Whether a form arrives does not decide whether your sale produced a gain you must report. The invoice and the resale settlement are how you show what you paid and what came back.

In Canada, the Canada Revenue Agency's July 2026 memorandum lists precious metal as a financial instrument and explains the treatment of financial services:

Supplies of financial services are exempt under Part VII of Schedule V unless specifically listed as zero-rated under Part IX of Schedule VI.

That is the CRA's distinction between supplies that are exempt and those taxed at a zero rate. Neither adds GST/HST to a transaction that meets the relevant rules. The general rule does not tell us whether a particular item qualifies as a precious metal or whether its sale qualifies for either treatment. We'd want the dealer to identify the item's form and fineness on the invoice and explain how it classified the sale. A later sale can still yield a capital gain if you held the gold as capital property, under the CRA's capital gains reporting guidance.

The Buyback Quote Can Change Which Form Wins

We favour a piece you can sell in the amount you might need. A larger bar can earn its place when the saving survives a check of the net bid and the cost of custody, and when you're prepared to sell it whole. A smaller bar can beat a coin when it gives you the same flexibility at a narrower round-trip spread. The choice is worth testing on the day the purchase price locks and again on the day you line up a sale, while you can still take a competing bid.

Gold can go up while the trade is still underwater.

Seek the truth and be prepared,

Equedia

Sources

Disclaimer: This letter is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Past predictions and performance are not indicative of future results. We own gold and gold stocks. Please see our full terms of use and disclaimer at equedia.com.

Many of our readers have made more than $100,000

Subscribe to our FREE monthly newsletter and see how many of our readers have made thousands in PROFITS with our ideas

Related Articles

What Is the 10-Year Treasury Yield?

The 10-year Treasury yield helps price mortgages and stocks. The real curve shows how the Treasury return that competes with bullion has changed.

Nov 21, 2026 · 9 min read